Chicago's Pizza Information

Walking into Chicago's Pizza at 1023 Payne St in Tell City, IN, immediately feels like stepping into a cozy neighborhood spot where everyone knows your name. The warm, casual atmosphere is inviting, with a mix of rustic décor and soft lighting that sets the stage for a relaxed meal with family or friends. The menu is classic yet satisfying, showcasing a variety of pizzas that range from deep-dish Chicago-style to thinner, crispy options, all generously topped and baked to perfection. One of the standout dishes is the stuffed pizza, where layers of cheese and savory toppings are encased in a perfectly golden crust, offering that rich, hearty bite that Chicago-style aficionados crave. Beyond pizza, the menu also features subs, pasta dishes, and appetizers like garlic knots and wings that pair perfectly with a cold drink, making it easy to mix and match for a complete meal. Service is friendly and attentive, with staff often going out of their way to accommodate special requests or suggest crowd favorites, creating a welcoming and personal dining experience. Reviews frequently highlight the generous portion sizes, consistent flavor, and the comfort of knowing you’re getting quality food without pretense. Whether stopping in for a quick carryout or settling down for a full sit-down dinner, the combination of approachable menu options, flavorful dishes, and relaxed atmosphere makes Chicago's Pizza a go-to for locals looking for a dependable, tasty meal in Tell City.

Open Times

Monday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Tuesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Wednesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Thursday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Friday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Sunday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Chicago's Pizza Gallery

Business Info

Location & Contact

Contact Details

1023 Payne St, Tell City, IN 47586, United States
Right Now :
+1 812-547-4060

What People's Say About Place

We took the vette out to wash...ended up in Tell City at Chicago Pizza! It was our first time at one....and we'll be back! Delicious! Clean and friendly as well!

Reminds me of the Cicis pizza in owensboro when I was a kid. We were able to take home a to go buffet box for about $14 that included salad bar choice, box full of pizza choice, and to go drink. The pizza tastes so good, most of the choices were thin crust pizza or original crust. With a few pan crusts that came out during our visit. Of course you have to top off with the cinnamon Stick pizza for dessert. Family friendly environment. My only complaint would be that our table we sat at was wobbly.

I'm not a huge pizza fan but I like the buffet & salad bar. It's a decent price with a decent variety. I also like the relaxing vibe & have yet to have an issue with the customer service

The pizza was SO good! I can't believe I've been missing out on this place for years, but I'll definitely be back!

I'm not a huge fan of pizza, but my husband and son are so we decided to stop by here while traveling. We were so impressed by the pizza! Everything was absolutely delicious and I honestly think it's the best pizza I've ever had. We had the deep dish with pepperoni, and the thick crust chicken bacon ranch. Both were phenomenal. Wish there was a location closer to home! We will definitely be returning when we are in the area

This is a good place to get a pizza, but the water tastes like tap water. Got a Sprite instead. Other than that, it's definitely worth the trip out here.

Good little place to stop and get lunch. Visiting Tell City and stopped for lunch. It was an all you can eat. The buffet is very small to what I am used to from Florida. Only two people could be at the counter at a time, so you would be waiting a lot on a real busy lunch. The pizza was really good and delicious. I definitely recommend checking it out. A little pricey for lunch and during the week but overall good experience.

Food was delicious and was very fast. Would definitely recommend. Next time I will try their deep dish pizza

Places Nearby

Bubble Tea Store

Fruity Bubble

50 Holyoke St, Holyoke, MA 01040, United States

Coffee Shop

Cafe Royal

1451 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362, United States

Bubble Tea Store

Yaaas Tea Syosset

334 Jericho Tpke, Syosset, NY 11791, United States

Restaurant

Spazio Pizza & Taps

2501 Memorial Pkwy SW, Huntsville, AL 35801, United States

Ice Cream Shop

Banana Split Llc

820 Church Rd, Aurora, IL 60505, United States

Southern Restaurant (US)

Mallards Southern Kitchen

2300 W 80th 1/2 St, Bloomington, MN 55431, United States

Chicago's Pizza